Historical safety totals before the later accident series
Four early financial years carry a different measure. They are shown here on their own and are not part of the safety chart.
Four early financial years
The Railway Board's report for 1959-60 publishes these totals in Statement 41(i), under the reporting rules introduced in 1951-52. [RB1960V2]
| Financial year | Published total | Unit | Scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1956-57 | 9,543 | reported events | Railways open for traffic in India; excludes Bukhtiarpur Bihar Light Railway |
| 1957-58 | 9,168 | reported events | Railways open for traffic in India; excludes Bukhtiarpur Bihar Light Railway |
| 1958-59 | 9,226 | reported events | Railways open for traffic in India; excludes Bukhtiarpur Bihar Light Railway |
| 1959-60 | 9,110 | reported events | Railways open for traffic in India; excludes Bukhtiarpur Bihar Light Railway |
These are evidence for the early years. They are not four missing values to paste into the later train-accident chart.
Why the boundary matters
The old table combines collisions, derailments, failures of engines and rolling stock, failures of permanent way, fires, and other accidents. The last category includes cattle on the line, train wrecking and attempts, road traffic at level crossings, obstructions and miscellaneous events. Its total is much broader than a modern consequential train-accident count.
The source says the 1951-52 rules separated collisions and derailments outside train operation, and raised the thresholds below which trivial events were not reported. The note refers to damage thresholds of Rs 500, or Rs 2,000 for property damage, and interruption thresholds of three hours for passenger and mixed trains or six hours for goods trains. These are historical rules, not current policy.
In all four years the table excludes the Bukhtiarpur Bihar Light Railway. A separate footnote says the fall in cattle incidents in 1956-57 was partly caused by Southern Railway changing its definition of cattle to match other railways from September 1955. Even a change within this old series can be partly a measurement change.
How to use these numbers
- Keep them apart from the later accident measure.
- Do not draw a continuous line from them to the later reported or consequential series.
- Do not describe the combined material as 70 years of comparable safety data. The core safety chart still covers 66 financial years under several incompatible definitions.